TL;DR
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Interior designers interviewed by House Beautiful describe a shift away from engineered quartz toward natural stone and porcelain, but the source does not establish that quartz is broadly disappearing from kitchens. It cites a National Kitchen & Bath Association report in which 78% of designers were sourcing quartzite and reports that California is preparing a production ban tied to worker exposure to crystalline silica.
Interior designers interviewed by House Beautiful say some clients are moving away from engineered quartz countertops in favor of quartzite, other natural stones and porcelain. The report points to changing design preferences, questions about quartz’s real-world performance and reported worker-health concerns, but it does not establish that quartz is broadly being phased out.
The report cites an annual National Kitchen & Bath Association trend report in which 78% of designers were sourcing quartzite, while fewer individuals were selecting quartz. That figure describes sourcing behavior for quartzite; the source does not provide the precise comparison for quartz, the survey’s full methodology or evidence that the material is disappearing from the market.
Designers quoted by House Beautiful say natural materials appeal to clients seeking variation and surfaces that change with use. Quartzite and marble offer natural patterns but can require more maintenance, while designer Jessica Risko Smith recommends soapstone and granite for clients looking for relatively low-maintenance natural-stone options. The designers also identify porcelain slabs as an alternative, including for clients on a budget.
The report also says California is preparing to ban the production of engineered quartz, citing concerns that crystalline silica exposure has been linked to silicosis among workers. It does not name the proposal, give a date or provide details about its scope or status. The health concern relates to fabrication work; the article does not say that installed countertops pose the same risk to household users.
Choices Beyond Engineered Quartz
Countertops are an expensive, disruptive part of a kitchen renovation, so a shift in designer recommendations can affect homeowners’ decisions well beyond appearance. The reported alternatives involve different trade-offs: natural stone can offer distinct patterns and develop a patina, but may need more care; porcelain is presented by the interviewed designers as a durable option, though the source gives no comparative testing or cost figures.
The health and regulatory issue matters for a different reason. Silica exposure is an occupational concern raised in connection with the production and fabrication of engineered stone. If California adopts a production restriction, it could affect manufacturers and fabricators there, but the article does not establish what products or activities a policy would cover, or whether other states are considering similar rules.
For consumers, the immediate takeaway is not that quartz is unavailable or categorically unsuitable. Rather, designers say expectations should match the material: stain-resistant does not mean stain-proof, and durability, maintenance, price and appearance vary by product and use. Homeowners comparing options may need to weigh those factors with a fabricator or designer before committing.
Products Worth Considering
KitchenAid 5.5-Qt Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer, Porcelain White (KSM55SXXX)
KitchenAid 8-Cup Grain and Rice Cooker with Integrated Scale, Porcelain White
Breville Smart Grinder Pro Conical Burr Coffee Grinder, Brushed Stainless Steel
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Why Designers Are Reconsidering Quartz
Engineered quartz became a familiar countertop choice because it offers consistent patterns, comparatively low maintenance and a look that can echo natural stone. House Beautiful’s report describes the current change as a shift in sentiment among designers, not a documented collapse in sales or a universal move by homeowners.
New York-area designer Barrett Oswald told the publication that quartz lacks the depth and individuality she associates with natural stone. San Diego designer Kilian Camp said she often takes clients to see stone slabs, after which some choose natural stone for kitchens or primary bathrooms. These are professionals’ accounts of client preferences, not a representative survey of all buyers.
Performance expectations also feature in the discussion. Santa Barbara designer Jessica Risko Smith said clients can expect a “worry-free” surface and be disappointed, while Steven Cooper of Cooper Pacific Kitchens said quartz is stain-resistant, not stain-proof. The report contrasts those expectations with growing interest in materials that show natural variation and signs of use.
““We’ve always felt that quartz lacks the depth, warmth, and individuality of natural stone.””
— Barrett Oswald, an interior designer quoted by House Beautiful
How Broad the Shift Really Is
The report does not quantify quartz countertop sales, market share or the rate at which homeowners are switching materials. The 78% figure concerns designers sourcing quartzite; without the report’s full survey details or a comparable quartz figure, it cannot show how quickly quartz use is changing.
The status of California’s reported production ban is also unclear from the source. It does not identify legislation or a regulatory agency, specify which engineered-stone products would be covered, or give an implementation date. The article reports a designer’s expectation that other regions may take precautions, but provides no confirmation of plans elsewhere.
There are no cost comparisons, durability tests or maintenance schedules for the alternatives in the supplied report. Recommendations are attributed to designers and may vary with the specific product, finish, installation and household use.
What Homeowners Should Watch
The next major policy detail to watch is whether California formally advances a production restriction and, if so, what materials, businesses and activities it covers. The source gives no expected decision date. Any claim that other states will follow remains a designer’s forecast rather than an announced policy.
Homeowners planning renovations can compare actual samples and ask suppliers about maintenance, stain resistance, repair, fabrication and total installed cost. For natural stone, questions about sealing and care may be relevant; for engineered quartz, buyers can ask what performance the manufacturer warrants and what the warranty excludes. The supplied report does not set out a single material as best for every kitchen.
As more market data or policy announcements become available, they may clarify whether the reported design preference is a lasting industry change or a trend among the designers interviewed. For now, the evidence supports a growing discussion of alternatives—not a confirmed end to quartz countertops.
Key Questions
What materials are designers suggesting instead of quartz?
The House Beautiful report names quartzite, marble, soapstone, granite and porcelain slabs. Which one fits depends on a homeowner’s priorities, including appearance, maintenance and budget.
Does the report show that quartz countertops are disappearing?
No. It describes designers’ changing preferences and cites sourcing data for quartzite, but provides no quartz sales figures or market-share data showing that quartz is disappearing.
What does the California ban claim concern?
The report says California is preparing a ban on the production of engineered quartz because of worker-health concerns related to crystalline silica exposure. It does not provide the proposal’s status, scope or timetable.
Is quartz stain-proof?
No countertop should be assumed to be stain-proof based on this report. Cooper describes quartz as stain-resistant, not stain-proof; buyers should check product-specific care instructions and warranty terms.
Source: housebeautiful.com
